When redecorating or repairing walls, knowing how to remove drywall anchors properly is essential. These small but sturdy fixtures can leave unsightly damage if extracted incorrectly. This comprehensive guide will walk you through nine professional techniques to remove all types of drywall anchors while keeping your walls intact.
Why Proper Drywall Anchor Removal Matters
Removing anchors carelessly can lead to:
- Large, uneven holes that require extensive patching
- Cracks spreading across the drywall surface
- Weakened structural integrity of the wall
By following the right methods, you can minimize damage and ensure a smooth, repair-ready surface.
Essential Tools for Removing Drywall Anchors
Before starting, gather these tools for efficient removal:
- Screwdrivers (flathead and Phillips)
- Needle-nose pliers (for gripping small anchors)
- Hammer (for stubborn metal anchors)
- Utility knife (to trim protruding edges)
- Drywall saw (for embedded anchors)
- Spackle or joint compound (for patching)
- Sandpaper (120-grit for smoothing)
- Putty knife (for applying filler)
Having the right tools ensures a clean removal process with minimal wall damage.
9 Effective Methods to Remove Drywall Anchors
1. Removing Standard Plastic Expansion Anchors
Plastic anchors are common for lightweight items like shelves and picture frames. Follow these steps:
- Unscrew the mounting screw – Back it out partially to loosen the anchor.
- Grip with pliers – Use needle-nose pliers to pull the anchor straight out.
- Push through if necessary – If it won’t budge, push it inside the wall and patch the hole.
Pro Tip: If the anchor breaks, use a utility knife to trim any remaining plastic flush with the wall.
2. Extracting Threaded Drywall Anchors
Threaded anchors (such as E-Z Ancor) have deep grooves for better grip. Remove them by:
- Twisting counterclockwise – Use a screwdriver to turn the anchor out.
- Applying pliers for extra grip – If resistance occurs, clamp down and twist.
- Patching minor wall damage – Fill small holes with lightweight spackle.
Warning: Forcing it out can enlarge the hole—work slowly.
3. Removing Toggle Bolts Without Damage
Toggle bolts have spring-loaded wings that expand behind drywall. To remove:
- Unscrew completely – Remove the bolt to release the toggle wings.
- Push inward to collapse wings – Gently press until they fold.
- Pull straight out – Extract the bolt smoothly to avoid wall tears.
Alternative Method: If the wings won’t collapse, cut the bolt with wire cutters and push the toggle inside the wall.
4. Taking Out Molly Bolts Safely
Molly bolts have a metal sleeve that expands. Follow this removal process:
- Loosen the screw – Turn it counterclockwise until the bolt loosens.
- Tap lightly with a hammer – This helps release the sleeve’s grip.
- Pull out with pliers – Extract the bolt carefully to avoid drywall tears.
Note: If the sleeve remains, push it in and patch the hole.
5. Removing Self-Drilling Anchors
These anchors screw directly into drywall. Remove them by:
- Unscrewing counterclockwise – Use a screwdriver to back them out.
- Using pliers for stubborn anchors – Grip and twist if needed.
- Filling small holes – Apply spackle for a seamless finish.
Tip: If the anchor spins freely, widen the hole slightly with a drill bit before extraction.
6. Extracting Metal Expansion Anchors
Heavy-duty metal anchors require extra care. Try this method:
- Remove the center screw – Take it out completely.
- Tap the anchor inward – Use a hammer to push it into the wall cavity.
- Patch the hole – Cover with joint compound and sand smooth.
Alternative: If accessible, grip the anchor with locking pliers and twist while pulling.
7. Removing Hollow Wall Anchors
These have a collared design that expands when screwed. Remove them by:
- Taking out the screw – Fully unscrew the center bolt.
- Prying the collar loose – Insert a flathead screwdriver under the edges.
- Pulling the anchor out – Gently wiggle it free to avoid wall damage.
For Stuck Anchors: Use diagonal cutters to snip the collar and push the remains inside.
8. Eliminating Drywall Anchors with a Drywall Saw
For deeply embedded or broken anchors:
- Cut around the anchor – Use a drywall saw to make a small square.
- Remove the anchor and drywall piece – Extract both together.
- Patch with a drywall patch kit – Secure a new piece with joint compound.
Best For: Large, damaged anchors that can’t be pulled out normally.
9. Using a Drill to Remove Stubborn Anchors
If an anchor won’t budge:
- Drill into the anchor – Use a slightly smaller bit to weaken it.
- Break it apart – The anchor should collapse inward.
- Patch the hole – Fill and sand for a smooth surface.
Safety Note: Wear safety goggles to protect from flying debris.
How to Repair Holes After Removing Drywall Anchors
After extraction, follow these steps for a professional finish:
Small Hole Repair (Under ½ Inch)
- Clean the hole – Remove loose drywall bits.
- Apply spackle – Fill with a putty knife.
- Let dry – Wait 2-4 hours.
- Sand smooth – Use fine-grit sandpaper.
- Paint over – Match the existing wall color.
Medium Hole Repair (½ Inch to 2 Inches)
- Insert a drywall patch – Use a mesh or adhesive patch.
- Apply joint compound – Spread evenly over the patch.
- Sand and repeat – Add a second coat if needed.
- Prime and paint – Blend with the surrounding wall.
Large Hole Repair (Over 2 Inches)
- Cut a clean square – Use a drywall saw.
- Install a backing board – Secure wood strips inside the wall.
- Attach a new drywall piece – Screw it into the backing.
- Tape and mud the seams – Apply joint compound and tape.
- Sand and finish – Smooth before painting.
Pro Tips to Avoid Wall Damage
- Work slowly – Rushing increases the risk of cracks.
- Use the right tool – Pliers, screwdrivers, and drills prevent unnecessary force.
- Patch immediately – Prevents further drywall deterioration.
When to Call a Professional
Consider hiring a drywall repair expert if:
- The wall has extensive damage
- Anchors are deeply embedded in load-bearing walls
- You’re unsure about structural integrity
Final Thoughts
Mastering how to remove drywall anchors properly ensures clean walls and hassle-free redecorating. Whether dealing with plastic, metal, or toggle bolts, the right technique makes all the difference. Follow these nine methods, repair holes correctly, and enjoy a flawless finish every time.
Now that you’re equipped with expert removal strategies, tackle any drywall anchor with confidence!
